Editors' Picks: Mascara

"I love this L’Oréal mascara: It can do a clean look for day—and with a little wiggle, a full lash for evening."

"So powerful, I’m pretty sure it could coax lashes from air. It gives unbelievable volume, thickness and definition—and it stays put all day long."

"A curved application brush is key for me—I maneuver it the way I want my lashes to go. Plus, it’s super-lengthening."

"I tried this because it’s paraben-free but became devoted because it makes my lashes enormous."

"The color looks great when light catches it. Also, if my eyes water (contact lenses), it actually looks nice when it runs, instead of giving me raccoon eyes."

"It’s hard to find mascara that thickens without causing the spider-leg effect. This one totally enhances, but in a way that looks natural."