Work with paler shades; you'll get the same drama but a different effect. It's earthy and pretty and natural, but it isn't a no-makeup look, either.
Brush on matte brown shadow as a base. Layer bronze and gold shadows at the corners of the eyes, and dust them lightly along the lid and brow.
Brown eye pencil all the way around creates the same almond shape and defines the whole look.
White pencil liner along the inside rim of the lashes makes everything pop.
Brown mascara keeps the subtle color thing going.