Shower gel update: Suggestions please!

I have loved SO many body washes over the years—but it just so happens that all of mine ran out at the same time, and I figured, why not change things up a little. What are your all-time favorites? These are the three I think I've loved the most, even though the only thing I think they have in common is their awesomeness:

1.Molton Brown Black Pepper Body Wash. This one rightly belongs to Jean, who has been a fierce Black Pepper Body Wash proponent for ages. Excellently spicy and peppery, as you'd expect, and not sweet at ALL. Can't even hazard a guess about how many bottles I've gone through in the past five years.

2.Johnson's Baby Oil Body Wash. God, so great: fresh-smelling, sweet in all the right ways, insanely moisturizing, and ridiculously cheap. The saddest beauty fact I've learned in recent months: This is officially being discontinued. Tragedy. I think you might be able to find it in certain drugstores, but not for long.

3.Ren Moroccan Rose Otto Body Wash. You know how everyone protests the scent of rose? This will completely change your mind. The scent is AMAZING—like a subtle, unplaceably beautiful perfume—and it's all-natural.

For the next move, I'm thinking of going old-school withNeutrogena Rainbathor Dr. Bronner's almond castile soap.Weirdly, I've never tried either one. But I gladly welcome other ideas...

--Cristina Mueller, senior beauty editor