does this outfit work?

Feb. 2008: Piper McEndarffer
february 2008

Piper McEndarffer, 23, featured in our February "Does This Outfit Work?" story, has always loved a horsey, riding-inspired look, but wondered if she was trying to do too much in one outfit: a Western-ish fringe scarf and bag, plus jeans tucked into super-tall, equestrian-style boots. Here's what we did to make it all a little more pulled together:

• Switched her over-the-knee boots for a pair of brown suede ankle boots sleek enough to fit under her jeans.

• Opted for a bag with a similar silhouette—but without fringe, so it doesn't compete with her scarf.

• Swapped her boxy cobalt blazer for a more snugly fitted black one.

"Piper's hunch was right," says fashion news director Jen Ford. "It's great to be inspired by a look, but it's important to remember that small doses can go a long way. We kept the focal point on one accessory—the bright orange scarf—and made everything else a bit more subtle."

Piper's reaction: "These booties make my legs look longer and leaner, and I feel more polished and less casual. And I love how my scarf really pops out against the black jacket!"

The Items We Chose:

Ankle Boots

Suede "Mercury" boots, $374, stuartweitzman.com

Fitted Blazer

Wool-blend blazer, $469, Development, shopbop.com

Handbag

Leather "Nikki" hobo, $607, Rebecca Minkoff, tobi.com

more on luckymag.com

Billboard Music Awards 2013: The Best Looks and How to Get Them

What Taylor, Selena, Nicki and more wore.

Betsey Johnson: From Iconic Designer to Reality TV Star

We are seriously excited about her new series.

Eight Reasons We're Definitely Over Wedge Sneakers

Our editors are so done with the wedge sneaker movement.

Seven Style and Beauty Secrets We Learned This Week

Click through for how to survive wedding season with one party dress, what to wear to a graduation and more.

100 Cheap Summer Finds to Heat Up Your Wardrobe

Without burning a hole in your wallet, of course.