Cons: Hanna's busy jacket is a bit much with her yellow belt. We would swap the mad plaid for a more subtle blazer and create a look that's not quite so Sherlock Holmes-y.
It's time to analyze Aria, Emily, Hanna and Spencer's looks from Tuesday's Pretty Little Liars episode, "Hot Water," in which the girls tried to outwit the schemes of creepy Detective Wilden. Which PLL had the best look this time around? Click through to find out. And remember, new episodes air each Tuesday at 8 pm EST on ABC Family. (As if you needed a reminder.)