Before American Horror Story: Coven was a thing, Sarah, Bonnie, Nancy and Rochelle were the original coven in The Craft. It makes sense, then, that the quartet of witches' favorite color scheme was black on black. The Supreme would approve. They may have traumatized fellow students and gotten struck by lightning (oh, wait, that was just Nancy), but I digress. They still rocked the goth-dark lipstick—well, dark everything—long before it was on the runways.
Click through to shop their looks.