img img
Stay In Touch

Lucky Mag is supported by our readers. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Futon vs. Mattress: Choosing the Right Sleep Solution for You

By: S I
Updated on: April 05, 2024
FAST FACTS

  • The comparison between futons and standard mattresses highlights differences in materials, versatility, back support, breathability, and durability.
  • Futons offer space-saving benefits and versatility, transforming from a bed to a couch, making them ideal for smaller living spaces.
  • Standard mattresses come in various types, including foam, memory foam, latex, innerspring, and hybrid, offering different benefits like support, pressure relief, and temperature regulation.
  • While standard mattresses provide more tailored support and durability, futons are known for their breathability and versatility, catering to specific lifestyle and space needs.

Are you in the market for a new sleep solution but unsure whether to buy a traditional mattress or a futon? With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to make the right choice. This comprehensive guide will compare the features, benefits, and drawbacks of mattresses and futons to help you find the best sleep solution for your needs. So, let’s dive in and explore the world of mattresses and futons.

What is a Futon?

Let’s start by understanding what a futon is. It is derived from the Japanese term futon, which refers to a bed frame with a mat or cushion filled with cotton or leaves. In the past, a Japanese futon referred to a padded mattress that could be rolled up and conveniently stored away during the day, making it perfect for small spaces that serve multiple functions. Today, futons have evolved to include various designs and materials, catering to different preferences and lifestyles.

Types of Futons

When it comes to futons, there are different types to consider. Let’s take a closer look at each one:

  • Traditional Japanese Futon: This type of futon is a bedding system rather than a mattress itself. It consists of cotton or wool with layers of padding for comfort. Unlike traditional mattresses, Japanese futons do not have springs. They typically consist of three layers: the base layer, the mattress layer, and the comforter or blanket (moku). Traditional Japanese futons are positioned on a tatami floor or mat for added comfort.
  • Western Futon Mattress: Western futon mattresses are unlike traditional futons because they have a frame, usually made of wood or metal, that can be changed into either a seat or a base for the mattress. These futons resemble sofa beds and are designed to provide both seating and sleeping options.
  • Bifold Futon Frame: Bifold futons are ideal for smaller spaces with limited floor area but more wall space. This frame type allows for more seating capacity when converted into a sofa-like structure. Bifold futons are common in living rooms, guest rooms, studios, and other compact spaces.
  • Trifold Futon Frame: Trifold futons are perfect for those with larger floor space. They offer extra legroom when in the lounging position and provide a cozy spot to rest on when fully converted into a bed. It’s important to measure your space carefully to ensure a trifold futon fits snugly when unfolded.

Are Futons Comfortable?

Comfort is a vital factor when choosing a sleep solution. Let’s explore the benefits and drawbacks of futons to help you determine if they are the right choice for you.

Benefits of a Japanese Futon

  • Multi-Purpose Area: A Japanese futon bed creates a versatile space that can be used for sleeping, sitting, or other activities. It allows you to maximize your small living area efficiently.
  • Restless Sleeper-Friendly: Japanese futons provide a safe sleeping experience for restless sleepers. Their firmness and support help reduce tossing and turning, promoting a night of more restful sleep.
  • Firmness and Support: Japanese futons are known for their firmness, which provides excellent support for the body. This can help people who have back pain or those who like their sleeping surface to be firmer.
  • Space-Saving: One of the significant advantages of Japanese futons is their compact design. They can be easily rolled and stored during the day, freeing up valuable floor space in smaller rooms.

Drawbacks of a Japanese Futon

  • Moisture Absorption: Cotton, the primary material used in Japanese futons, tends to absorb moisture from perspiration. It’s essential to air out the futon mattress regularly to prevent odors and maintain its freshness.
  • Storage Requirements: Rolling and storing a futon mattress daily can be challenging for some individuals. It requires a dedicated storage space or a large closet to accommodate the futon when not in use.
  • Thin Profile: Japanese futons are thinner than traditional mattresses, which may not be suitable for those who prefer a taller sleep surface. If you prefer a more elevated bed, a futon may not be your best choice.

Benefits of a Western Futon

  • Versatility: Western futons offer versatility, serving as both a couch and an extra sleep space for guests. They are an excellent choice for those who need a dual-purpose furniture solution.
  • Style Variety: Western futons are available in different styles, allowing you to select a design that suits your interior décor and personal preferences. Whether you prefer a modern or traditional look, there’s a futon style for everyone.
  • Comfortable Seating: Unlike traditional futons, Western futons are designed to be as comfortable as regular couches. They provide a comfortable seating experience, making them perfect for lounging and relaxation.

Drawbacks of a Western Futon

  • Less Thickness: Western futon mattresses are generally less thick than traditional ones. If you prefer a more substantial sleep surface, a futon may not provide the level of thickness and plushness you desire.
  • Conversion Hassle: Converting a futon from a couch to a bed and vice versa can be a hassle for many users. It requires some effort and can be time-consuming, especially if you frequently switch between modes.
  • Space Requirements: While futons are space-saving options, they still require ample space when fully converted into a mattress. Ensure you have enough room to accommodate the extended futon before making your purchase.

Is a Mattress a Better Option?

While futons have advantages, it’s also essential to consider more traditional beds and mattresses. Mattresses have evolved significantly, offering improved comfort, support, and durability. Let’s explore different types of mattresses and their features.

Types of Traditional Mattresses

When it comes to traditional mattresses, there are several types to choose from. Each type offers unique benefits and features. Here are some common varieties:

  • Polyurethane Foam Mattress: Polyurethane foam mattresses, also known as polyfoam mattresses, are the most affordable option available. They are made from petrochemical-derived materials and can be found in mattress toppers and furniture cushions. While polyurethane foam mattresses are budget-friendly, they may not provide the optimum support and durability that some sleepers require.
  • Memory Foam Mattress: Memory foam mattresses consist of blended polyurethane and other substances. This blend gives memory foam its visco-elastic features, enabling it to mold to the body’s natural curves. Renowned for offering great support to the back and joints, memory foam mattresses are favored by sleepers seeking tailored comfort.
  • Latex Mattress: Latex mattresses offer a lightweight and bouncy feel. Some shoppers prefer latex mattresses because they are typically made from natural materials. Their open-cell structure makes latex beds breathable and highly comfortable, especially for hot sleepers. They provide adequate support for various sleeping positions and are considered one of the most durable mattress options, with an average lifespan of 15 years.
  • Innerspring Mattress: Innerspring mattresses are some of the oldest mattress varieties. They consist of inner coils and a foam layer on top. Innerspring mattresses are firmer and thicker than foam mattresses, providing a push-back feel when sleeping. Different types of innerspring beds include Bonnell spring, continuous coil, offset coil, and pocketed spring beds.
  • Hybrid Mattress: Hybrid mattresses combine different mattress materials to maximize their advantages. They typically consist of a comfort layer, support core, and base layer. Some hybrid beds include additional features like a pillowtop layer or cooling layers for enhanced comfort. Hybrid mattresses are designed to offer a balance of support and pressure relief.

Japanese Futon vs. Standard Mattress: A Comparison

Now that we have explored the features of both futons and traditional mattresses let’s compare them side by side to help you make an informed decision.

Materials

Standard mattresses can be made from various materials, including foam, natural latex, innerspring, or various components. Many modern mattresses incorporate additional layers to enhance comfort. However, it’s important to note that some conventional mattress top materials may release volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are potentially harmful.

On the other hand, a Japanese futon is a regular mattress traditionally made from cotton batting and a cover. Cotton is a comfortable and breathable material that is generally safe for the skin, making it suitable for allergy sufferers and babies.

Versatility

When it comes to versatility, futons take the lead. Their lightweight design allows for easy folding and storage, making them the best choice for smaller spaces. Futons can be quickly transformed from a bed to a couch or sofa bed, providing flexibility and maximizing the functionality of your living area.

Standard mattresses offer versatility in terms of the benefits they provide to sleepers. Different bed mattresses and materials cater to various needs, such as back support, pressure relief, and temperature regulation.

Back Support

Both futons and standard mattresses offer back support but to differing degrees. Standard mattresses are designed to offer proper spinal alignment and support, making them ideal for sleepers with back pain. They are engineered to accommodate different sleeping positions and promote a healthy sleep posture.

Although firm and supportive, Futons may provide limited back support and pressure relief due to their thinner and lighter design. If you require a thicker mattress for significant back support, a standard mattress may be a better option for you.

Breathability

The breathability of a sleep surface is crucial for a comfortable night’s sleep. Standard mattresses’ breathability depends on the materials used. Foam mattresses, for instance, may not be as breathable as latex or innerspring mattresses. Hybrid mattresses are designed with cooling layers and open-cell structures to promote better airflow and breathability.

Futons, on the other hand, are made of cotton, which is known for its breathability. Cotton enables better air circulation, keeping you cool during hot nights. It also has moisture-absorbing properties, making it suitable for those who tend to sweat during sleep.

Durability

Durability is a vital factor to consider when investing in a sleep solution. Standard mattresses are designed to last, with an average lifespan for regular mattresses ranging from 6 to 15 years, depending on the materials used. Latex mattresses, known for their durability, can last up to 15-20 years with proper care.

Futons, like any other mattress material or bedding option, are subject to regular wear and tear. However, they may not hold up as well as traditional mattresses over time. Futons may develop lumps and lose their shape, affecting their support and longevity.

Personal Style

Your personal style and preferences are vital in choosing an air mattress as the right sleep solution. Futons have a more traditional look and feel, while standard mattresses give a room a modern touch. The choice between the two will depend on your interior design preferences and lifestyle.

FAQs about Futon vs. Mattress

Let’s answer some common questions about futons and standard mattresses to provide further clarity.

How Long Does a Futon Mattress Last?

The average lifespan of a futon mattress with regular use is typically around five to ten years. Futons used in guest rooms may last longer since they receive less frequent use.

How Long Does a Standard Mattress Last?

The lifespan of a standard bed or mattress depends on several factors, including the materials used and the quality of construction. Innerspring mattresses generally have an average lifespan of 5-7 years, while hybrid mattresses can last 7-10 years. Memory foam beds typically last 8-10 years, while latex mattresses have the longest lifespan, lasting 15 years or more.

Are Japanese Style Futons Comfortable Enough?

The comfort level of a Japanese futon depends on the quality of materials used. Higher-quality futons are thick and supportive enough for both sleeping and sitting. However, it’s important to note that futons are designed to be used on the floor. If you find getting up from the floor challenging or prefer a more elevated sleeping surface, a futon may not be the best sleep solution for you.

Choosing the Right Sleep Solution

Ultimately, the choice between a futon and a standard mattress depends on your needs, preferences, sleeping space, and lifestyle. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, and both options have their pros and cons. It’s crucial to consider your health, comfort requirements, and available space when deciding.

In conclusion, investing in a quality sleep solution is a significant decision that can greatly impact your overall well-being. Whether you choose a futon or a traditional mattress, both options offer unique benefits. Take the time to research, test different options, and consider your personal preferences to find the perfect sleep solution for a restful night’s sleep.

img
 

Feeling Lucky?

Sign up for updates and
exclusive deals.