img img
Stay In Touch

Lucky Mag is supported by our readers. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Mattress Pad vs. Mattress Topper

By: Christina Davies
Updated on: April 05, 2024
FAST FACTS

  • Mattress pads and mattress toppers serve different purposes: Pads primarily enhance comfort and provide slight protection, while toppers significantly alter mattress firmness and support.
  • Mattress pads add a subtle layer of plushness and protection, while mattress toppers can make your bed softer or firmer, extending the lifespan of your mattress.
  • Consider your desired feel, protection needs, budget, and cleaning preferences when choosing between a mattress pad and a mattress topper.
  • Mattress pads are generally more affordable, while mattress toppers come at a higher price point.
  • Choose the bedding accessory that best aligns with your specific needs and preferences to enhance your sleep experience.

If you want to enhance your sleep experience, you may have come across various bedding accessories that claim to improve comfort and provide additional benefits. Two such products that often cause confusion are mattress pads and mattress toppers. At first glance, they may seem similar, but they serve different purposes and can have varying effects on the overall feel of your bed. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between mattress pads and mattress toppers, discuss their benefits, examine their construction, and help you understand which one might be better for your specific needs.

What Is a Mattress Pad?

A mattress pad is a thin sheet of material positioned on top of a mattress to change its texture and offer a degree of safeguarding. Usually around 1 to 2 inches thick, mattress pads are not designed to drastically change the firmness level of a bed. Instead, they offer a slight adjustment to the comfort level by adding a layer of plushness.

Mattress pads can be made from a combination of synthetic and natural materials, each offering different benefits and effects on the overall feel of the bed. For example, a mattress pad made with feathers can provide a plush feel and soften a very firm mattress. On the other hand, a wool mattress pad can add coziness to a stiff bed while regulating temperature and wicking away moisture. Fiber mattress pads, made from polyester fill, are lightweight, soft, and machine-washable, making them a cost-effective choice for those looking for extra cushioning without compromising movement.

A mattress pad’s primary purpose is to modify a mattress’s comfort level. It can make a very firm bed feel softer or add structure to a softer mattress. Some waterproof mattress protectors and pads can protect your bed from spills, accidents, dust, mites, and other allergens, depending on the model. While mattress protectors are specifically designed for protection, they can be noisy and less comfortable compared to mattress pads.

Benefits and Types of Mattress Pads

Mattress pads offer several benefits depending on their construction and materials. They can enhance the comfort level of your bed, protect your mattress, and provide additional benefits such as temperature regulation and allergy prevention. Let’s explore some of the common types of mattress pads and their specific benefits:

Feather Mattress Pads

Feather mattress pads, made with duck or goose feathers, provide a plush feel and are suitable for softening a very firm bed. The feathers also offer breathability, preventing heat buildup. Numerous feather mattress pads incorporate a baffle box design to ensure the even distribution of the filling. However, feathers may clump over time, resulting in an uneven surface unless the feather mattress pad is regularly fluffed.

Wool Mattress Pads

Wool mattress pads, sourced primarily from sheep, offer natural moisture-wicking properties and temperature regulation. Wool is frequently employed in mattresses and mattress pads due to its natural fire-resistant properties. A wool mattress pad can enhance the comfort of a firm mattress without excessive heat retention.

Fiber Mattress Pads

Made from polyester fill, fiber mattress pads are a suitable choice for individuals sensitive to down feathers. They are lightweight, soft, and machine-washable. Fiber mattress pads provide extra cushioning without inhibiting movement and are generally more affordable than other types of mattress pads. Temperature neutrality can be based on construction, but most fiber pads offer decent breathability.

What Is a Mattress Topper?

Unlike mattress pads, mattress toppers are thicker and more substantial layers of material designed to significantly change the firmness level of a mattress. It can range from 1 to 4 inches in thickness. Latex mattress pads and toppers are made from various materials and are not primarily intended for mattress protection.

Mattress toppers come in many sizes to fit standard mattress dimensions and may feature elastic straps to ensure a secure fit. They can alter the comfort and support of a mattress by making it softer or firmer, depending on your preferences and sleep quality.

Benefits and Types of Mattress Toppers

Mattress toppers offer a range of benefits, including the ability to modify the feel of a mattress, extend its lifespan, and provide pressure relief. Here are some common types of mattress toppers and their specific advantages:

Memory Foam Toppers

Memory foam mattress toppers provide deep pressure relief by cradling the body and alleviating tension. They are an excellent choice for side sleepers or lightweight individuals who have firm mattresses. Memory foam toppers also excel at isolating motion, making them a popular option for couples looking to minimize sleep disturbances.

Latex Toppers

Latex toppers offer contouring without excessive sinkage. They provide ample pressure relief while still offering enough bounce for ease of movement. If you want a memory foam topper to increase the firmness level of your mattress, a Dunlop latex topper is a denser option. Talalay latex, on the other hand, is more breathable and suitable for individuals who tend to sleep hot.

Wool Toppers

Although less common, wool mattress toppers are sought after for their softness and breathability. The wool mattress topper excels at temperature regulation, making it suitable for all seasons. Wool toppers provide an additional layer of comfort while allowing air to circulate, resulting in a more comfortable sleep environment.

Feather Toppers

Feather mattress toppers offer a soft and fluffy feel. They vary in terms of support, and some designs layer different types of feathers memory foam mattress toppers to strike a balance between plushness and loft. Feather toppers regulate temperature well and are versatile for different seasons.

Mattress Pad vs. Mattress Topper: Key Differences

Now that we understand the benefits and types of mattress pads and mattress toppers let’s compare them to determine which is the right choice for you. While both products offer comfort enhancement, the primary difference between latex mattress toppers lies in their intended purpose and the extent to which they modify the feel of a mattress.

Use

Mattress pads are primarily designed to increase the comfort of a bed and protect the mattress from accidents and contaminants. They offer a slight adjustment to the feel of the bed without significantly altering its firmness level. On the other hand, mattress toppers noticeably change a mattress’s feel and provide extra support and pressure relief. Toppers can revitalize an old mattress or extend the life of a new one.

Feel

A mattress pad adds a subtle layer of plushness to a bed but does not alter the firmness level of the existing mattress itself. It enhances comfort without significantly transforming the way the bed feels. In contrast, a mattress topper creates a more pronounced change in the feel of a mattress. Depending on the type, a topper can either soften or firm up a mattress, enabling a more personalized sleep experience.

Durability

Durability may fluctuate depending on the materials and workmanship, but typically, most mattress toppers endure for a span of 3 to 5 years. Similarly, an average mattress pad should maintain optimal performance for a comparable duration. However, it’s important to note that the lifespan of both products can be influenced by usage, maintenance, and quality factors.

Cost

When it comes to cost, mattress pads are generally more affordable than mattress toppers. Mattress pads can range from $20 to a few hundred dollars, depending on the type and quality. On the other hand, mattress toppers are usually more expensive, with the average queen-size topper costing between $150 and $400.

Cleaning & Care

Mattress pads are often machine-washable, making them relatively low maintenance. They can be easily cleaned and dried, ensuring a clean and hygienic sleep environment. Mattress toppers, conversely, may pose greater cleaning challenges because of their bulkier design. While most mattress pads and toppers do have removable covers that can be machine-washed, the interior components often require spot treatment. Some designs may even require dry cleaning. Following the care guidelines provided by the manufacturer is crucial for preserving the durability and effectiveness of your mattress pad or topper.

Making the Right Choice

When it comes to selecting between a mattress pad and a mattress topper, it ultimately depends on your personal needs and preferences. Consider the following factors to make an informed decision:

Desired Feel

If you’re looking to fine-tune the feel of your bed and provide modest protection, a mattress pad may be the right choice for you. They offer an extra layer of plushness and can protect your mattress from dirt and spills. Mattress pads are a low-maintenance solution for sleepers who want to add comfort without significantly changing the feel of their bed.

On the other hand, if you’re seeking a more noticeable transformation in the comfort and support of your current mattress top, a mattress topper is a better option. Toppers can make a mattress softer or firmer, depending on your preferences. They can improve the performance of an older mattress or protect a new one from premature wear.

Protection Needs

If protecting your used memory foam mattress topper from spills, accidents, dust, mites, and allergens is a priority, a mattress pad with specific protective features may be more suitable. While some mattress toppers may have a waterproof barrier, most are not specifically designed for protection against liquids or other contaminants.

Lifespan and Budget

Consider the lifespan and budget when making your decision. Both mattress pads and mattress toppers have comparable lifespans, typically lasting between 3 and 5 years. However, the cost of mattress toppers is generally higher than that of mattress pads. Evaluate your budget and invest in a product that aligns with your financial considerations.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Think about your cleaning preferences and routines. If you prefer low-maintenance options, mattress pads are often machine-washable, ensuring easy cleaning and care. Mattress toppers, on the other hand, may require more attention due to their bulkier design and internal components. Consider your willingness to follow specific care instructions and choose a product that suits your cleaning preferences.

By considering these factors, you can make a well-informed decision and choose the bedding accessory that best suits your needs and preferences.

FAQs 

Are mattress pads and mattress toppers the same thing?

No, they are not. While they both add comfort to your mattress, mattress pads primarily serve as a protective layer, while mattress toppers are designed to enhance new mattress comfort and alter the mattress’s feel.

Do I need both a mattress pad and a mattress topper?

It depends on your specific needs. If you’re looking for extra protection and a touch of comfort, you might consider using both. However, in most cases, one or the other will suffice.

How often should I replace my mattress pad or topper?

It’s recommended to replace your mattress pad or topper every 3-5 years, depending on its quality and wear.

Can a mattress topper make a firm mattress softer?

Yes, a mattress topper can add a layer of softness and comfort to a firm mattress, making it more plush and inviting.

Do I need a special mattress pad for allergies?

If you have allergies, it’s advisable to choose a hypoallergenic mattress pad designed to prevent allergens from accumulating on an uncomfortable mattress.

Can I use a mattress topper on an old mattress?

Yes, a mattress topper can revitalize an older mattress by providing a plush layer of additional support and comfort.

Conclusion

In summary, mattress pads and mattress protector toppers are distinct bedding accessories that serve different purposes. While mattress pads primarily focus on adding a layer of plushness and providing modest protection to your mattress, mattress toppers are designed to significantly change the feel and support of your bed.

When choosing between the two, consider factors such as desired feel, protection needs, lifespan, budget, and cleaning preferences. By understanding the differences and benefits of mattress pads and mattress toppers, you can make an educated decision and enhance your sleep experience accordingly.

img
 

Feeling Lucky?

Sign up for updates and
exclusive deals.